Restaurant reviews are paramount to our industry, and we love listening to your feedback. It is very easy to leave us feedback about our cuisine and service on social media right from your mobile device. Below we have listed some reviews from Facebook, Google, and Yelp. Our primary goals are to serve you better, and to serve amazing food. Please don't forget to check in on Facebook, when you are dining with us!
Chandra Marie
2022-05-17T02:38:04+0000
Hilltop catered our wedding this past Saturday for over 200 people and it was absolutely incredible!!! We knew from our... tasting that Hilltop was our winner! Everything was amazing; the display, the service, the ease and speed of the buffet and most importantly the food!!! We had people coming up to us all night raving about how this was the best food they have ever had at a wedding and people called and sent texts the next day still raving! Crystal is amazing and went above and beyond to ensure that we had a perfect celebration! We cannot thank Hilltop enough for helping us have the wedding of our dreams!read more
Cindy Myers Schmitt
2022-05-07T21:43:37+0000
While we have dined at Hilltop several times before and have always loved their food, we attended a baby shower today... where it was catered by Hilltop. The food was outstanding! If we ever decide to have a family party or other event in the future catered, we will definitely have Hilltop Restaurant & Bar do the catering!read more
Alexander Stack
2022-04-11T04:13:21+0000
I come here for lunch on Friday’s sometimes, and look forward to it every time. Amazing food, bartender is awesome. ... Seriously, the food is amazing for the priceread more
Jennifer Schnobrick
2022-02-25T23:58:19+0000
We went to do a catering tasting for our daughter and future son in laws wedding. We told them in emails, over the... phone and in person about allergies that our son in law has and we were insured that they would not use any of the things he's allergic too. Needless to say, about 30 minutes into the tasting he started getting an itchy throat and he was in a lot of pain. He was having an allergic reaction. But why would he when they knew what not to use? Their were 6 of us there in what was supposed to be an exciting time and my father had to leave to take him home to take his medication. That never should have happened. When telling the owner what happened, she said she would see what happened. A day later she got back to us saying that her Sous Chef used sesame seeds in a sauce(which we specified he was severely allergic to). She did nothing. We are very blessed that he is alright now after a horrible night but we no longer trust this place. With their negligence, this could have been a totally different outcome. Thank God it wasn't. Definitely not going with them got the wedding or ever going there again. The only good thing was the server we had. He was very nice.read more
Ashly Kidney
2022-02-20T07:00:26+0000
The food was absolutely amazing! Appetizers all the way to dinner. Shrimp, French onion soup, salads, salmon, steak,... rosemary chicken... AMAZING! I have one tip, have one person handle the hostess station!!!! I walked in the door 5 minutes prior to my reservation, that I made the day prior. One girl helped me, said she had to clear a table to seat us. Ok, thank you! Another girl walks up asking if we've been helped. Yes, thank you! Next the owner walks up as another group is walking in. We're standing out of the way but still very visible. Our table is given away to the 4 walking in after us. We were asked after who came in first. Um, us! Reservation from Thursday night. Needless to say we waited another 20 minutes for a table. No big deal. But...had one person been handling the hostess station, our girl wouldn't have felt terrible to come back and speak to us. Excellent food. My grandmother loves the food. Just disappointed in how the reservation was handled.read more
Karl Sholtz
2022-01-07T23:19:24+0000
Great food and the menu changes frequently. They have something for everyone to eat. 4 star food with a home style... atmosphere.read more
Kris Swider-Burns
2022-01-01T20:01:35+0000
Dinner was absolutely amazing last night. The service was nothing but perfect.🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
Shannon Layman
2021-12-22T02:23:14+0000
Dinner was amazing as always. My son doesn't do well with big crowds so this was a perfect way for him to see Santa... !! Thank you for a wonderful evening ! You have the best staff !read more
Laura Jordan
2021-11-26T19:56:24+0000
We had the Thanksgiving meal yesterday and it was delicious! Hot and ready on-time with generous portions. Thank you... for offering this dinner. It was very much appreciated and enjoyed by myself and my family!read more
Deanna Randolph Atkin
2021-11-26T18:20:02+0000
We got the Thanksgiving Meal. Thank you for offering these. Everything was delicious!!!
Jeremy Horanburg
2021-11-26T00:39:36+0000
Purchased their Thanksgiving meal again this year, because it was so good last year. They did not disappoint,... everything was delicious. Owner & staff were very nice & the food was great. My wife and I decided thay we need to go out for dinner there more often.read more
Maria Shilling
2021-11-25T21:50:27+0000
We purchased the $130 Thanksgiving dinner and it was fabulous. Everything was delicious. The turkey was so moist and... tasty. All of the sides were exceptional. The portions were more than generous. Hubby travelled an hour to pick this up and it was sure worth it.Thanks to all the staff at Hilltop for doing such a great job.read more
Michelle Haseley
2021-10-21T23:16:48+0000
Such a amazing restaurant and amazing food but the best part was our amazing, friendly, funny waiter Demetrius!!!! **
Janice Carter Quill
2021-10-09T00:09:40+0000
Very busy but everyone was very friendly. Would definitely go back
Gretchen Bruning
2021-10-01T01:54:04+0000
We ordered a couple family packs for a family dinner. The lasagna was so tasty & everything was delicious. The service... from ordering to pick up was excellent. Thank you for making my night easy to entertain on a work night.read more
Wayne Teaven
2021-09-25T23:39:28+0000
great food and a great wait staff headed by the quarterback (bartender). They're lucky to have her and her team
Jessica Lea George
2021-09-14T13:08:56+0000
I chose Hilltop to cater my wedding and I just have to say I am 500% impressed. First things first we came for a... tasting and our server Demetrius was the most personable funny person I’ve ever experienced. Not only was their food absolutely delicious, one of the owners Crystal was an absolute blast and extremely helpful and prompt in any way she could be. I couldn’t recommend this place enough. As a born and raised Buffalo girl I was so proud to have such immaculate chicken wings at my wedding. I will most definitely be back for dinners and any other big events I may need in the future. Thank you guys so much for everything!read more
Kia N Clark
2021-08-19T23:20:46+0000
I ordered takeout today and my food was less than disappointing. I got an all American burger and asked for no tomato... but substitute onion, that didn't happen, (no biggie) my fries are very undercooked like they've been sitting around, the lettuce in the salad and on my burger is wilted and almost slimy. The employee who answered asked how I wanted the burger cooked, I said medium but I got well done. The roll that came with my boyfriends meal could knock someone out! There was also no napkins, forks, knives, salt or pepper. not everyone that orders takeout is taking it home. I won't come back for takeout maybe to dine in if this doesn't sway me away from them alreadyread more
Allie Mary
2021-08-18T00:33:50+0000
Five stars all the way! Its a hidden GEM. I go here probably at least every 2 months or so because it’s that good. They... catered my wedding, and we just go for all of the family’s birthday celebrations. Excellent. The owners work hard and are great entrepreneurs. This place is worth your money, and I am never disappointed when I try a completely new dish that’s out of my comfort zone. Great spices, textures, and flavors in the food. Everything is always cooked to perfection and hot when it comes out. Our favorite place. Check this place out if you want a great tasting meal. You will not be disappointed. We always enjoy the nice African waiter he’s upbeat, great sense of humor, and keeps the positivity under the pressure of the busy nights. Now that I talked you into it, go eat there!😄read more
Julianne Elizabeth
2021-06-21T14:52:15+0000
We had our wedding catered for an offsite wedding and it was amazing! Multiple guests said the food was the best... wedding food they have ever had. Every request was covered. Crystal and her staff made our wedding an even better day than we expected. Thank you again Hilltop ! We will be booking for all our future events ! 💕read more
Nickie Girardo
2021-06-21T05:06:42+0000
Hilltops Catering is always ON POINT! Fresh, hot and delicious ! by far best Catering food around! and you can't beat... Crystal's customer service. She goes above and beyond every time ! I've worked with a lot of caterers and Hilltop is by far the best!read more
Caitlyn Swiatowy
2021-06-07T22:41:36+0000
Hilltop catered our wedding and we were beyond happy with the experience. Crystal is so accommodating and easy to work... with. Our guests raved about the food and our photographer said it was the best wedding food she has ever had! We will be using Hilltop for any future events we may have!read more
Kimberly Marie
2021-05-30T22:40:46+0000
We decided to try this place out last night. Never had beef on weck before, never heard of it since we’re from the... Chicago area. It was delicious! My kids both had giant burgers and they said they were awesome. Fried pickles were the best we’ve ever had! Demetrius was an excellent server. Very kind and attentive. Hilltop is a wonderful restaurant.read more
Sue Rosky
2021-05-30T01:21:38+0000
Great food have gone there several times for dinner and every time the service is great. The staff is so friendly just... a really good experience! Highly recommendread more
Sarah Kathleen
2021-05-03T14:36:40+0000
Amazing, delicious, fantastic...were just a few of the words our guests used to describe Hilltop Restaurant’s catering... for our event. From start to finish, Crystal was wonderful to work with and went above and beyond to ensure we had everything we needed. The food was OUTSTANDING! We cannot wait to work with them again.read more
Charlie Nowak
2021-04-04T15:38:57+0000
Went last night for beers and wings . Had a GREAT experience !!! The wings were some of the best I’ve had in years,... they came out fast and hot and they were fresh. The staff was great, everyone had a good attitude and they really worked together as a team, nice job Hilltop !!! See you soonread more
Adam Mis
2021-02-15T00:21:46+0000
Food was outstanding. The service was excellent. It was a nice comfortable atmosphere and everyone seemed to be... enjoying there evening. I will be going back. Great menuread more
Nolin Jackson
2021-02-09T23:08:22+0000
the BEST fried pickles I've ever had. food never disappoints, love the variety and the always changing specials. can't... say enough good things about this place.read more
Mike Andrews
2021-01-20T04:44:33+0000
Always the best food/daily specials in Lockport. Demetrius was fantastic in meeting all of our needs. Never been... disappointed. Cannot wait to go back yet againread more
Arin Snellings
2021-01-17T01:07:13+0000
What a great meal! Demetrius made it a great experience for us too. Can’t wait to go again and try more things from the... menu.read more
Patti Gioeli
2021-01-17T00:05:17+0000
Spent my birthday here and the 5 of us all had a wonderful dinner. Burgers, chicken and waffles and short rib carnitas... were among our favorites. Took smoked wings to go and they were insane. Our server, Demetrius, hit it out of the park as far as service goes. We will be back again and again. Great job!read more
Mary Jo Mittelstadt Mcdonald
2021-01-14T15:16:32+0000
Ordered a family meal yesterday, it was excellant!!! everything was delicious! Thank you!! Meal was here in 40 minutes
Paul E Wann
2021-01-09T01:29:46+0000
Wow what an awesome dinner with my wife. Outstanding!!! Great service and EVERYTHING tasted wonderful. Maybe the best... place we have experienced since we moved to the area 18 months ago. Can’t wait to go back!!!read more
Monica Sutkaytis
2021-01-06T00:01:51+0000
The food, atmosphere & service was amazing!! Id highly recommend, the food was outstanding and I couldn’t say better... things about the service... if we ever come back to the area, we’ll forsure come back here!read more
Lisa Wilhelm Seaborn
2020-12-05T22:44:27+0000
The food was absolutely delicious and great service! Make sure to get the candied jalapeño cheddar hush puppies!! We... will be back many times!read more
Alicia Calderone
2020-12-05T12:37:42+0000
Horrible. I had googled good fish fry’s in lockport, because i always go to the same places. So we decided to try here.... Had reservations for 630 for 4. We all order fish fry’s and specials. After 20mins the tell us they are all out. We almost left but chose other entrees. (in which they were out of baked pot &other things)I ordered stuffed meatballs and showed the owners daughter they were stuffed with nothing. 2 balls of meat! The waiter was friendly and it wasn’t his fault. I had asked to talk to the owner but she was “out making deliveries” Her daughter was friendly and i explained to her our poor experience-the whole place was ran by 20 year olds and younger with no owner in sight. They need to get it togetherread more
Mike Moran
2020-12-05T03:09:57+0000
Can’t even begin to put into words how amazing the experience was... food is beyond delicious ... service and... atmosphere was perfect ... hats off to the owners and staff... well done !read more
Kimberly Combs
2020-12-05T02:09:13+0000
The food is fantastic. EVERYTHING is homemade 😋😋Y'all....they even make their OWN BUTTER!! 🧈🧈❤️❤️So Far; We've had... their Pizza (homemade dough) /Wings, Chicken/waffle dinner, Spare Rib dinner, Porterhouse steak dinner & the Broiled Fish Fry- GET THE HOUSE RUB for the fish fry!!! TRUST ME. I'm a picky B***h, if I say it's good, it's GOOD!! The service is OUTSTANDING each & every time!! LIKE LEGIT! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐👍👍read more
Wendy Stymus
2020-11-27T00:13:26+0000
We ordered the Thanksgiving package from Hilltop. This is the first time we have ever ordered out. I was excited to... relax for once, yet nervous about it tasting good. Well, it was AMAZING! Everyone at my table was impressed. It was hot and ready to go when we picked it up. I literally carved the turkey, took the stuffing out, and served. No stress, and it was better than what I would've made. It was tasty, the turkey was juicy, the sweet potatoes were good enough to be a desert. We will definitely order again if they have it. We will be watching for a Christmas menu. It was worth every penny. Well done Hilltop, well done!read more
Jason Dale
2020-11-27T00:00:33+0000
We've loved this place for over 4 years now. Both owners are chock-full of give-a-damn. I rarely go to a restaurant... more than 2x, mostly due to disappointment and knowledge that I can do it better at home. Been here more than 2 dozen times, and it's always first-rate. This time, Hilltop put together a complete Thanksgiving to-go dinner. Everything was as perfect as if they only made it for one family. When I got there, it was all packed up, hot, ready to go, ready to serve. While I love putting together an elaborate spread for the holiday, I just didn't have it in me. Crystal, Tony and the staff put it together, and the whole family loved it. Thanks Hilltop!read more
Ashley Kyle
2020-11-26T20:36:07+0000
We ordered the Thanksgiving dinner, hubby picked it up today at 2pm. Food was still hot and steaming when he got home.... Everything was delicious!!! The only thing we were absolutely disappointed about is that we paid 15.00 for a pumpkin pie 🥧 from ALDIs, they just slapped their hilltop sticker on it. 😡 like cmon, couldn’t you of use a local bakery?read more
Tiffany Howell
2020-11-25T02:19:30+0000
Every single thing we have ever ordered from the Hilltop has been phenomenal. I am completely addicted to their house... dressing, and the chicken and waffle sandwich with the sweet potato fries is incredible. We try to order something new every time, and every time we have had an excellent meal. Tonight I ordered the “Perfect Winter Salad,” and it was indeed perfect. The staff is always kind, and provides great service. Keep up the great work, Hilltop crew! Highly recommend!read more
Roy Kaczynski
2020-11-21T00:23:41+0000
Great food...good selection of beer & wine.....great atmosphere....... As Arnold once said "I'll be back!" .
Ram Thenua
2020-11-12T01:00:22+0000
The great Dr.iyobo everyone has been talking about on the internet has also help me with his love spell last week... Wednesday he restore my broken relationship and brought my ex back to me. i have been with a broken heart for the past 6months after my ex broke up with me but after i have read online about Dr.iyobo ❤️❤️ spell i was really pleased to contact him for the chance that i have got to get my ex back, after Dr.iyobo has cast the spell for me my ex came back to me after 48 hours which is last week Friday. With so much joy in my heart i want to appreciate Dr.iyobo for his great help he render to me. incase you need his help you can alsocontact him via his email driyobo67@gmail.com Whatsapp and his mobile number is +2348132917235https://www.facebook.com/Dr-iyobo-love-spell-and-divorce-Spell-testimony-home-111791010644391/youread more
JenniferandBrian MacFarland
2020-11-12T00:36:35+0000
Raspberry barbecue chicken wings were amazing and we are definitely coming back!!!! 10 stars
Michelle Candino Kauhl
2020-10-31T21:58:17+0000
Seriously awesome Prime rib !! We have never had an ok dinner here- EVERY time we come it is fantastic!! 100%... recommend!!read more
Roberta Gilly Keirn
2020-10-18T00:29:41+0000
The Tavern steak is fantastic! Best meal out in forever! Great service, great food, great night!
Nancy Monacelli Moore
2020-10-13T22:14:30+0000
The food, service and presentation was absolutely perfect for our daughters wedding! Every guest that I spoke with just... raved about the food!! VERY reasonably priced and again, Crystal was just so very helpful with everything, not just the food but everything! Highly recommend for your party, shower, wedding, whatever and don’t forget to stop at the restaurant for lunch or dinner!!! Just amazing 🤩 Thank you Hilltop, Crystal and staff!!read more
Nicci Nicholson
2020-10-13T19:27:49+0000
Hilltop catered my wedding this weekend and it was nothing short of AMAZING. The guests are still raving about the... food, especially the brisket and Mac and cheese! Crystal was amazing to work with, before and during the wedding. I 100% recommend using them as a caterer and will be using them in the future!read more
Beth Costello
2020-09-12T23:59:14+0000
We ordered the steak special tonight with creamed spinach, mashed potatoes, salad and bread for take out.Absolutely... Delicious!! Seriously we couldn’t finish our meals. So excited for left overs tomorrow lolThank you Hilltop for a fabulous meal and the nicest waitress at the drive thru. We will be back again!!Honestly if you haven’t ordered from here you are missing out!!read more
Bob Brechue
2020-08-22T08:24:52+0000
My kids were in town and asked if we had every been here. Always wanted to try it but never did. Long story short,... WOW!! Great food and Great service. We have eaten here 6 times in the last 3 weeks and every time it's been delicious!read more
Debbie Naples
2020-08-16T01:49:03+0000
My husband and I noticed this place and stopped for an early dinner on August 15th. We had the most amazing salmon... dinner I think we’ve ever had! Charming atmosphere and vey friendly waiters/waitresses. We sat inside for the air conditioning but it has an amazing large patio. What a great find! We will definitely be back!read more
Ken Packer
2020-07-26T22:48:43+0000
I want to thank you for the great job you did on my catering order this past Saturday. It made my sons grad party a... hit with all the guests. The food was fantastic! The pulled pork was amazing and I don't say that lightly. The service was great from the order taker to the chef who prepared the food and helped me load my car.Great job, and I won't hesitate to use Hilltop again for my catering.read more
Kevin N Annette Lamb
2020-07-25T13:42:26+0000
catering menu is amazing, Lots of variety. Excellent quality and taste local. The customer service is top notch. Any... question you have, is answered speediciously. Used Hilltop for our family gathering following funeral. Great price. Definitely recommend using Hilltop for your catering needs. It's great to give these local restaurants/ caterers business. And they deliver it hot and fresh from their kitchen. 5 stars and 2 thumbs up👍👍⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐read more
Bonnie McKie
2020-07-03T00:05:04+0000
Awesome food. Very nice wait staff. Nice patio to eat outside. Loved it!
Michelle Cable Wood
2020-06-09T20:16:48+0000
We had take out today, it was our first time here. What an AMAZING meal, you will be seeing A LOT more of us. We can't... wait to try more menu items!!!!!!read more
Dawn Donoughe Prohaska
2020-06-04T23:57:35+0000
We just had the short rib care package and a family side salad. Everything was excellent as usual. We have ordered... many of these specials over the last couple months!!read more
Steven Scharlau
2020-05-31T23:47:45+0000
Got the takeaway today as usual staff so professional and food is always soooooo good.
Kara Bigsby Kirk
2020-05-17T00:22:46+0000
Just had a GREAT dinner from Hilltop! Pulled pork care package, smoked wings...enough food for 2 meals! Everything was... DELICIOUS!!!! Highly recommend!!!!read more
Jay Faraci Glynn
2020-05-11T15:18:36+0000
We ordered the pistachio salmon and short ribs last week. Incredible! Portion sizes are huge. We had enough for two... meals. So easy. Order by phone, drive up and order is handed to you outside. Will do it again this week. From the phone call to order to pickup, employees are amazing!read more
Michael Anthony
2020-04-30T22:00:39+0000
This place is absolutely phenomenal.... my wife and I order entrees for ourselves then something we haven’t tried on... the menu yet to split!! Between dining in and take out I’ve visited here about a dozen times and just when I think it can’t get any better, then next experience trumps it.. Compliments to the Chef and staff!read more
Robin Dearborn
2020-04-24T22:24:47+0000
During this Pandemic we have tried to support as many local places as possible. Hilltop Restaurant & Bar is the one... that we constantly go back to. They are hands down the #1 spot for us. I have not had a more consistent experience anywhere else.The staff is always friendly, and helpful. The food is AMAZING! and you get so much for the price. I have very picky eaters and they LOVE everything we have ordered. Thank you Hilltop owners and staff for all that you do! You have never disappointed us.read more
Alli DeVlieger
2020-04-15T20:30:57+0000
How I've never written a review is beyond me. We've been enjoying Hilltop for years. It is our favorite restaurant in... the area hands down. We eat here almost too much if that's possible. Everything is always delicious. The owners and staff are friendly and welcome you like family. Their pickup and delivery service during the shutdown has been the best we've encountered! ❤❤❤read more
Rachel Sandle-Sacco
2020-04-14T23:05:45+0000
Just wanted to post how much we enjoyed ordering from you during this pandemic. It’s the first time we have tried your... food based on a recommendation from a friend, food was delicious, pick up process was easy and safe, free kid’s meals were a hit! We will definitely be in to sit down and try your food again when this is all over with. Thanks again!read more
Haley Alfiere
2020-04-08T21:17:57+0000
Thank you for serving the staff of Newfane Rehab! We appreciate it more than you know during these uncertain times.... Everything was excellent!read more
Wendy Wilson
2020-04-08T01:26:01+0000
Tonight we were very pleased we chose Hilltop to purchase pickup. We had the Meatloaf wrapped in bacon, and also the... smoked pork meal. plenty of food for couple days, and very delicious! Highly recommend and so glad they were open.read more
Gordie Fletcher
2020-04-06T16:03:45+0000
Hilltop is a true community minded small business. they have proven to be an incredible asset during this outbreak... crisis. please try them if you haven't already. They do not disappoint! Great people, during any time.read more
Steph Wodo
2020-03-26T03:27:27+0000
Thank you from Eastern Niagara Hospital Emergency Department for bringing us the delicious food. It is very much... appreciated!read more
Amy Kinyon Brown
2020-03-26T03:18:35+0000
We ordered the rotisserie chicken package and it was amazing! They brought it out to my car so pick up was easy. The... chicken was delicious, as were the mashed potatoes, green beans, and loaded potato soup. So much food that we have some leftovers for lunch. We’d love to get this again and help support our local restaurant.read more
Nancy Schenauer Neidrauer
2020-03-22T13:30:55+0000
I had a fish fry that was absolutely delicious. I also had a appetizer. Definitely would go back again
Tonishea Noonan
2020-03-21T21:58:30+0000
10 STARS!!!! Domtop Pizza, Raspberry BBQ & Garlic Parmesan Wings are absolutely delicious!!! Thank you for providing... pull up, “curbside” service during this “Covid-19 Madness” once the chaos subsides and we are back to normal life, we look forward to dining in!!read more
Julie Pierpoint
2020-03-21T21:42:17+0000
We’ve eaten there multiple times prior to now. The food is always fantastic! The service is always fantastic! We... ordered from there tonight. They delivered. The food was amazing!!! I can tell you that this is a restaurant that we will always support! I’m sure all the restaurants are doing the most they can. This just endeared themto me forever! One of the best places ever!!! Thank you for your hard work in taking care of us all in this time!!!!read more
Janelle Bitterman Lembke
2020-03-20T00:32:17+0000
This place is amazing during our crisis! Delivered outside an amazing amount of food for 35$ feeds a family of more... than 6. They even sent a beautiful care package home for my kids! A++++ Tysm Hilltopread more
Allison Harmon
2020-03-18T23:09:51+0000
Just enjoyed our pulled pork package and buy an order get an order wings. Everything was delicious! There's still... plenty left for dinner tomorrow.read more
Lee Ann Miles Cogar
2020-03-18T22:32:19+0000
We just had your smoked pork family meal. Just wanted to let everyone know it was DELICIOUS, and a great price for the... food we received! Everyone support your local restaurants, they have bills to pay too!read more
Kimberlie Hoefler Miller
2020-03-18T20:50:43+0000
Ordered the bacon wrapped meatloaf package for four tonight for dinner. It was amazing! We’ll get another meal out of... it too! Thanks so much!read more
Annie Baker
2020-03-17T23:04:34+0000
We ordered dinner tonight to support a local business. It was hot upon delivery, VERY generous portions & HIGH quality... food!read more
James L. Owen
2020-03-16T18:30:11+0000
Open for dinner later than most places in the area on Fridays. Dimitrius is a gem!
Christine Smyczynski
2020-03-08T00:46:53+0000
Everything was tasty and the wait staff was friendly and knowledgeable
Deborah Taylor McCanna
2020-02-15T04:02:17+0000
it was awesome..waiter was great..food was awesome..never had a bad meal there
Erron Stoddard
2020-02-15T00:46:31+0000
first I would like to apologize to the bar tender for my attitude....but I think he understand completely were it was... coming from. We had reservations for 7, 7:20 came and were still at the bar no table. so I decided to order from the bar. We ordered ..he came back to tell me they didnt have the appetizer I ordered no prob I ordered something different. Then they came back to tell me they had no shrimp which is my second option for an appetizer as well as my husband's entree! like come on you have a special menu for valentines day and dont have what's on the menu!?! then offered us a free drink and shot which neither of us even ordered alcohol....so after wasting 45 min of our time with having reservations and never even sitting at a table we are on our way somewhere else and hopefully can get a table seeings how its valentines day. Not to mention the food is way overpriced. Last valentines our dinner was great and I waited a year to come back for that special menu for nothing. I left the free shot coins as well because I will never be back.read more
Shelley Ward
2020-01-26T21:57:36+0000
Great food. The prime rib was tender and the tavern steak was cooked perfectly
Immacolata Burtless
2020-01-10T23:22:50+0000
I never really write a review because I really don’t eat out, my daughters suggested take out for dinner tonight they... are huge fans of the chicken wings, shrimp over coleslaw and amongst other favorites. I said I was good and to go ahead and order wings, they insisted I order something because I don’t eat wings.. I ordered the stuffed meatball over fettuccine with marinara sauce, my kids reminded me that I would never eat it because I never do, I was born and raised in Naples, Italy. I watched my dad and mom cook all that are today the finest dishes of Italy.The meatballs are a HUGE and so delicious, even better than mine..those mini meatloafs are so tasty and moist...OMG they were sitting on top of fettuccine and topped with Marinara sauce..Call me crazy but I know a good fettuccine and I am thinking they are homemade not sure but they sure taste like it. Marinara sauce was also very fragrant with a touch of sweetness.Thank you and compliments to the chefs I will reorder again and again. 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏❤️❤️❤️👌👌read more
Jessica Stewart
2020-01-01T19:03:10+0000
A few of us stopped in for dinner on NYE and the food and service were both amazing! We have been there a few times... before, and every time the food is delicious!read more
Jennifer Annunziato
2019-12-29T04:01:53+0000
My friend and I went to the Hilltop tonight. We had drinks and split French onion soup, sweet and spicy shrimp, wings,... and soft pretzels. We stuffed ourselves and EVERYTHING was amazing, down to the very attentive and courteous bartender who took care of us. Thank you!read more
Heidi Kelkenberg Feltz
2019-12-24T18:25:33+0000
Hilltop catered our holiday lunch at work yesterday. So delicious! I was lucky to have left overs for lunch today.... Their chicken cordon blue was my favorite, love the crispy breading on it.read more
Leslie Stoianoff Baker
2019-11-29T23:43:46+0000
Went on a whim and I don’t know why we haven’t tried this place sooner 😊
Elizabeth A. Roberts
2019-11-14T00:28:59+0000
Wednesday night wings are amazing. Wings are smoked and grilled. Flavor is out of this world. Hilltop fiesta lime salad... was delicious. Great atmosphere and service. Definitely will be back to try something new.read more
Ivy Angela Rivera
2019-11-04T05:10:24+0000
Perfection! Different, delicious and will haunt me in my dreams. Just how great food should be.😋
Christie Clark Paulison
2019-10-19T20:54:34+0000
All of the dishes we have tried so far have all been amazing 😉 our fav is the chicken & waffle sandwich!
Michelle Fuax
2019-10-15T00:55:17+0000
best food!!! This place is amazing! It's like family as soon as you walk in. Staff is awesome, food is delicious.... Hilltop will NOT disappoint!read more
Shannon Kerth Kimber
2019-10-05T13:09:02+0000
The food is always amazing! We have been there 4 times now and the Seafood Scampi was phenomenal, it was so delicious!... The service was great and the atmosphere was beautiful.read more
Dale Powers
2019-10-04T22:32:58+0000
When we want to go out to eat with a guarantee of a delicious dinner and great customer service we always choose... Hilltop Restaurant!! Hilltop has never been a disappointment!! So if you're coming into Lockport from out of town and want a great meal stop in to Hilltop!!read more
Lydia Bielicki
2019-09-26T13:23:33+0000
Great little place with interesting and delicious food. The wings here are amazing! Try the raspberry bbq and parm... garlic! Also, the wait staff is excellent. Every server we have had has been efficient, knowledgeable, and very friendly.read more
Donna Eick
2019-08-07T06:21:10+0000
Caesar salad delicious as always..loved the cornflake crusted chicken with buffalo slaw! French dip an amazing beef... sandwich and of course great service..thank you Hilltop!read more
Tim Lederhaus
2019-07-27T00:47:43+0000
Alaina was a GREAT waitress! We loved our food. Great restaurant!
Josh Sterling
2019-07-20T22:53:17+0000
Awesome food as always! Never been let down with the service and taste of food. Phenomenal!!!
Susan St Onge Beyer
2019-07-20T00:16:22+0000
I loved the French onion soup and the chicken lilly was amazing!
Amber Ellis
2019-07-07T21:08:55+0000
I've been to Hilltop for dinner and have always had a great meal. My review today is to comment on the phenomenal... catering they provide! We had a surprise party on July 6th and the food was the talk of the party! Crystal was responsive and worked with us to make sure our menu was perfect. The staff that dropped off and picked up was very helpful.The FOOD: wings, pulled pork, brisket, beef on weck, pretzles, chips salsa and guac, wraps and sandwiches...everything was phenomenal, everyone loved it and took menus home. Can't say enough good things about them!read more
Melissa Leigh
2019-06-30T14:26:27+0000
Loved the patio, food was delicious, amazing chef, very polite and friendly staff! Win win all around!!!
Ann Marie
2019-03-08T22:23:25+0000
Went tonight for Fish Fry and it was INCREDIBLE! THE best I've ever had!My boyfriend says the coleslaw was delicious as... well. And their homemade bread AND butter. Do yourself a favor and try them out!read more
Paul Taylor
2019-03-01T19:08:06+0000
Great food. Shentelle, our server, was friendly and attentive. We’ll be back.
Roberta Bull-Spoth
2019-02-23T01:38:17+0000
Great experience!!!! Great service- so important. And food options were awsome!!! Atmosphere was very welcoming and... very pleasant!! Over all- 5 star-Loved it!!!!read more
Amy Tonner
2019-02-20T00:45:10+0000
My husband and I went to dinner on Sunday. I can honestly say that was the best dinner we have had out in a very long... time. The service was friendly and fast. All the food tasted great and was unique. You can tell they take pride in every dish making it fresh. Even the salad with your meal was good. It wasn’t just a bag of ice berg lettuce opened and thrown into a bowel. I would highly recommend Hilltop for your next dinner out!read more
Brittany Burns
2019-02-18T01:24:02+0000
We came here with our church for a Valentine’s Day lunch, and everything was fantastic!
Gail Blount
2019-02-11T17:29:34+0000
From a hand press burger to pistachio crusted fresh salmon, to chef carved prime rib. Oh and all the meats they smoke... in house ... One word, DELISH!read more
Tyler Hill
2019-01-06T00:49:40+0000
Great food, better service. Every time I come home I make sure to stop in and get a bite to eat. Can’t go wrong with... any of the specials!read more
Brianna Brogan
2018-12-22T22:24:20+0000
Huge thanks to the hard working staff at Hilltop Restaurant & Bar for coming together post pandemic and making our... Housewarming BBQ a success!!! The retro mac n’ cheese was a huge hit as was the corn bread and apple cranberry slaw - all kid friendly! Will definitely be utilizing Hilltop for future events!!!read more
Mike Denniston Sr.
2018-12-13T17:13:16+0000
everything there is great, had wings last night, been eating wings for like forever, and I have to say the ones I got... last night were over the top, best ever, as for 5 stars, if I could I would give them double that to 10 stars, there's only one thing about the dining area my wife and I think needs to be done, give it some color , gray and black are fine but put some color in to cheer people up , like bright color curtains, colorful pictures, just bright colors, but the food is to die for, believe me, try itread more
Barbara Kandris
2018-10-10T14:30:22+0000
The food is the best I have eaten can’t wait to visit again 👌👌👌
JodyLyn Whipple
2018-09-14T02:16:14+0000
First time here. They catered our rehearsal dinner for 23 people. Everything was set up nicely when we got there. The... food was deliciously amazing!! Everyone couldn’t stop talking about how amazing the bruschetta chicken and beef on weck was! The staff was super helpful and friendly! I would recommend this restaurant to anyone who hasn’t been here. Again I want to say thanks to the staff, you all are amazing!read more
Randi Scholes
2018-09-09T10:05:14+0000
just had the chicken and waffles last night and it was amazing! literally love everything on the menu
Brandon LaRoach
2018-09-02T01:05:02+0000
Just had the worst burger of my life the bun was so hard and dark it was like they cooked it with the burger. Also we... waited 45 minutes for 2 burgers and it wasn’t even packed. Also some one came in after us and ordered wings and they were done before our burgers.. the only thing good was our waitress Mia who was new and trying to do her job the best she couldread more
Maya Sharon Rosenblath
2018-08-31T16:20:07+0000
My wife and I came here last night to celebrate our 4 year wedding anniversary and were very impressed. Our waiter,... Patrick, was amazing! Also, I have to eat gluten-free for health reasons and was blown away that any item on their menu can be made gluten-free! We will absolutely be back! 🙂read more
Jessica Malloy
2018-08-29T02:57:29+0000
Had a fantastic dinner tonight! The Prime Sirloin was AMAZING! Pork poutine and artichoke dip were awesome as well! The... house dressing is SO GOOD and as always the specialty butter was divine! 5 stars for sure!read more
Catherine Schmidt
2018-08-05T01:28:51+0000
Everything was amazing, service, food, bill it was amazing!
Jill S. Chudy
2015-12-22T20:42:57+0000
The restaurant was cute, clean, and nicely decorated. The wait staff was friendly, knowledgeable & patient. The food... was AWESOME! Thank you Anthony & Crystal ~the dynamic duo behind this fantastic restaurant!read more
Chris Luce
2018-07-22T23:47:03+0000
Shantilzzlle my nizzle great server all around. She really good!!
Jacqueline Ferris DeCarlo
2018-07-13T01:01:03+0000
Very loud! Tables too close together, kids running aroundOrdered wings for an appetizer, came AFTER dinner...should... have been comped, they were notService lousy!!Took my son-in-law and daughter out for a birthday dinner....what a disappointment!read more
Jennifer Diel
2018-07-08T23:52:53+0000
Went there this evening for my parents 30th wedding anniversary because they had never been and have been wanting to... try it. Everything was fantastic. I’ve been many times, food is always great. Can’t wait to go back again!read more
Greg Fenzel
2018-06-22T03:53:08+0000
My wife and I had dinner last night, it was amazing! Great service, great food and awesome staff! I will definitely be... going again!!!read more
April Lambert Flick
2018-06-20T15:28:19+0000
super slow when owners arent there. when they give you the wrong sandwich but u eat it anyways because you know it will... be another hour. when you have to ask for bread and butter to hold you over after already waiting 40 minutes.. gotta say i have never had a margarita with sugar????? that part could just be me.read more
Dan Dolansk
2018-06-20T03:51:20+0000
My wife and I stopped off here after a round of golf and we truly enjoyed our time here. We were greeted by a very... friendly hostess who took us to our seats promptly. Patrick, our waiter, was very helpful and cheery in explaining the daily specials and answering our questions. I decided on the pork chops that were thick! The bone-in thick cut pork chop was topped with a delicious sweet chutney. Simply amazing. My wife decided on the lobster mac n cheese that I could see was full of lobster and very creamy. (She loves cheese)..After eating, there was no room left for dessert. As we left, we ran into the owner of the restaurant and she chatted with us for a few minutes about her family and some upcoming events this summer at the restaurant. What a friendly place!!!If your'e looking for a great dinner, this place is a gem!read more
Kelly Ehrenreich Albone
2018-06-20T01:12:58+0000
First time there tonight and I will never go back! There was 2 tables that got there ahead of us and 2 tables that came... in behind us. 1 of the 2 tables that came in behind us got their food before we did. After waiting 1 1/2 hrs we finally received our food. Had to chase someone down not once but twice to get a refill of water. Kids running in and out of the kitchen. My wings were over cooked. Had our food not come out when it did I was walking out. The only positive I can say right now is the waiter was very nice and did apologize for the wait. First time and the last time!read more
Brian Smith
2018-06-11T22:44:26+0000
Food is always good, service has been lacking the past few times and not because of the waitress, more so because of... under staffing... please owners help your staff you have good food!!!read more
Sarah Waltz
2018-06-04T01:00:42+0000
Absolutely wonderful time for our Grandkids Luncheon today!! Our service rocked!! The food was AMAZING!! We will be... back!! Great job!read more
Alison Nesbitt
2018-06-03T18:15:38+0000
DELICIOUS! We had Hilltop cater the sides to our wedding reception. I can't say enough good things about our... experience, from the tasting to the actual day! highly recommend to anyone for catering events! Very affordable, especially for the amazing quality. Tony was great to work with, and we had a really great experience with something that could have been very stressful for those planning a wedding.read more
Rachel Haseley
2018-05-11T21:31:57+0000
This place is a gem! If you’re looking for amazing food and good service, this place is for you! If you can’t make up... your mind about what you want then the ever changing specials will be sure to please! I love going there just for the specials! You won’t ever say “been there, done that” or need something “new” or “refreshing” because this place does that all on their own! Can’t recommend a better place and I’ve NEVER had a bad meal here!read more
Terry Kirkpatrick
2018-03-24T21:18:17+0000
I love my blueberry beer.....and it tastes very well with their pistachio crusted salmon....yum❤
Shawna Snyder
2018-03-11T23:44:58+0000
We just did a food tasting for our wedding and LOVED IT! So many options to choose from and they are so flexible!!!
Veronica Kruger
2018-03-11T22:55:24+0000
Came for a wedding tasting- everything was absolutely amazing from the service to the food.
Debra Allport
2018-03-03T21:31:01+0000
Had the Chicken & Waffles, and the Chicken & Shrimp Scampi...and of course, an appetizer of Fried Pickles...absolutely... delicious. The sauce on the scampi was different than any other I've had and was the best!read more
Sue Eckert
2018-02-16T23:33:06+0000
I love this restaurant. Everytime we eat here the food is delicious. Best fish fry around!!
Chris Hollenbeck
2018-02-15T02:12:50+0000
I took my girlfriend to hilltop restaurant for a Valentine's day dinner and I could not have been more satisfied. The... atmosphere was welcoming and family friendly. The sirloin steak and all the other dishes we had were delicious.read more
Susan Perry Atwater
2018-01-22T03:13:45+0000
We really enjoyed our meal last night! The prime rib was delicious, the salad was beautiful and the house dressing... yummy. I had Jack Daniels chicken and popcorn shrimp over sweet potatoes and it was wonderful. The service was excellent, everyone so friendly and happy! I will come again soon!read more
Anne Marie Holland
2017-11-13T11:25:24+0000
Went to the Hilltop this past Saturday, 11/11. We had the smoked prime rib. It was extremely tender and delicious. ... Salad was a nice size and was able to substitute asparagus for baked potato. The asparagus was done just right - not to mushy and not too hard. Another person in our party of 4 had the harvest platter. The serving was huge and he said it was delicious. The service was very good! Too bad they don't have the prime rib every weekend.read more
Bernadette Sunshine
2017-08-31T21:49:59+0000
Just ordered take out. Everything was delicious and the blue cheese shrimp tortellini was amazing!
Katie Pacillo
2017-06-19T00:30:37+0000
First time going yesterday, had the bbq beef brisket, it was absolutely delicious. Super tender and great taste. Highly... recommend.read more
Greg Birke
2017-06-05T00:38:55+0000
I/we have been to this restaurant numerous times. We have had parties of over 10 to just the 2 of us. We have never had... a bad meal here. If you have a large party make a reservation. And as my favorite server Patrick says if you can't decide between a special or something off the menu. Go for the special, the menu items will be here next time. Prime rib weekends are every other weekend. Be sure to check out a prime rib weekend at least once. Yummy smoked prime rib.read more
Tiffany Mikits
2017-05-21T21:59:45+0000
Great food and excellent service!!!! Gourmet food at reasonable prices! Definitely going to make it a regular spot!
Katelyn Rose Mazurkiewicz
2017-05-20T00:21:05+0000
Best food and drinks around!!!! Great atmosphere and excellent service!
Michelle Cobo
2017-04-29T16:37:31+0000
Exceptional food and service! This is our new favorite restaurant in this area. We will definitely be back, and will... highly recommend to all our family and friends!read more
Brooke D'Argenio Unversaw
2017-04-12T14:20:29+0000
Love Hilltop Grill!!! There is something for everyone!! Even the kids love it!! Friendly environment and delicious... food....what more could you want!! Reservations are a must but they have even accommodated us when we walked in!!! Patrick is very sweet and an excellent server!!!read more
Jason Kaese
2017-04-09T02:09:03+0000
Great food, good beer wish they had more on tap but good selection micro bottles. Good atmosphere, the bar has that... hometown little watering hole feeling . It would be nice hitting the bar up after a days hunt. Will be back againread more
Meghan Kwaczala
2017-04-02T23:01:04+0000
Food was great. Our waiter/Bartender had drinks for us before we even realized we needed them!! Definetly will be going... there again. I also was able to make reservations for our large party so no waiting when we arrived 💙read more
Kristin M Ferington-Teeter
2017-04-02T22:58:34+0000
My husband and I dine here regularly! We took friends who have never been, last night,. I want to say how awesome our... server, Chris was! Besides having a great meal he made the whole night for us! Never had to ask for a drink, when it got low he, showed up w another! His personality was amazing! Hope when we come back again he will be there! Our friends have decided this will be there new go to place!read more
Pam Parker
2017-03-26T23:24:52+0000
Excellent food and friendly service...must return for lunch soon
Brandon Long
2017-03-26T15:50:40+0000
We go here more and more. Staff has always been great and accommodating. Owners have always been very nice and the food... in my opinion is some of the best around. We always recommend this place to family and friends. I don't think I have ordered the same thing twice because there are so many different options. If I had to pick my favorite it would be between the beef stroganoff or the smoked wings (sweet chili) both were very pleasing. I haven't been displeased at all. Great place , highly recommend!read more
Brandi Sutter
2017-03-19T02:34:47+0000
went for the first time tonight. our waiter was great! are food not so much! I got there special, the filet tower with... 2 5oz filet and I only got 1, they made it to my liking but my steak had no flavor at all, the potatoes where hard, and my husband order a stuff burger, he said it didn't taste well at all. we both got salads, and they both had a funny taste! pretty expensive dinner for not tasting to good. we won't be going back anytime time soonread more
David Arnold
2017-03-12T23:24:56+0000
Loved the place, great food and great owners and cooking staff.
Mark Lembke
2017-03-12T15:57:33+0000
Food and staff are awesome!!! Prime rib was outstanding last night and Bailey's cheesecake was so delicious!!
Curt Noon
2017-03-12T00:19:15+0000
Had reservations still had to wait. It was like nobody had a idea what was going on. Then our meals finally came, but... the steaks were all under cooked and had to send back,but they never got our salads. So the salad came after the meal. This used to be a fun place to go with good food. But lately it has gone backwards.read more
Thomas Hillman
2017-02-20T00:27:23+0000
My steak was delicious,cooked just right. The staff was very nice.
Meg Marie
2017-02-19T01:59:47+0000
My husband and I went to dinner here tonight. The food was delicious and the staff was wonderful! We will be back again!
Stacey Hopkins Johnston
2017-02-15T14:12:15+0000
Just had an awesome Valentine's dinner at the Hilltop. Amazing service and food as usual. Definitely a favorite local... restaurant! Great bar atmosphere too. Always different specials going on and a great menu with wide variety I have never been disappointed there. We will be back soon!read more
Kelly Chaffee
2017-02-13T01:30:18+0000
Amazing food need a bigger dinning area and more parking space but a great dinner every time
Aaron J Smith
2017-01-28T05:55:02+0000
Great food and drinks. I have been there twice and the food has been outstanding both times!
Aj Roberts
2017-01-17T19:48:45+0000
We had a fantastic lunch here today. I highly recommend this place and we are definitely going back.
Tammy Way
2017-01-14T11:50:23+0000
Thank you Patrick for making our dinner feel like a special occasion. Thanks food was top notch and your suggestions... were spot on....Loved itread more
Maureen Henderson
2017-01-12T22:48:15+0000
Amazing! My family has eaten at the Hilltop many times and it never disappoints. The food is fresh and delicious and... the service is top notch. We're big chicken wings fans and theirs are THE BEST we've ever had. I recommend the sweet chili creamy.;-)read more
Shantel Dawn
2017-01-12T00:22:57+0000
Every time we've ate here, the food has been amazing. The staff is great, and it's a great comfortable atmosphere.... Definitely recommend! !read more
Janet Krantz Roger
2017-01-09T16:17:55+0000
Went To Hilltop for lunch last Saturday. Good choice. We both enjoyed our time there and the food. Tuscan Vegetarian... wrap w/ grilled chicken and Ernie ordered the Shrimp Po' Boy . Both very good . Keep up the good work !read more
Ellie Elaine Marie McFalls
2016-12-23T05:48:36+0000
The food was phenomenal but it took us 1-1/2 hrs to get 20 wings...
Barb O'Reilly McGaffin
2016-12-18T01:28:24+0000
Leonard Oakes wine, great food and first rate service!
Chrystal Sharp
2016-12-04T00:06:10+0000
Went there for the 1st time, great food, our server Tony was amazing. The place was packed and still had quick service... !read more
Kathleen M Ginty Wick
2016-11-27T02:54:47+0000
Best Salmon I've ever had anywhere! Great service, try this restaurant out you won't be disappointed!
Tom Angelo
2016-10-28T00:55:52+0000
Great food and great workers that really make it feel like home best wings I've ever had !!
Kevin Tattersall
2016-10-18T22:20:29+0000
Had our family function catered from Hilltop 2 weeks ago...Crystal and Tony were so easy to talk to and food was... FABULOUS! ! Everyone was impressed. .even with being from Canada it is soooooo worth the drive! !! Sorleys and Tattersalls�read more
Sharon Weis
2016-10-17T17:36:26+0000
Wonderful food created just for us. We are vegetarians and eat out very little since we don't think some establishments... care about our choice. Everything was amazing including owners and servers. It felt like visiting friends in a cozy relaxed atmosphere. Can't wait to go again.read more
Joseph Young
2016-10-10T18:16:25+0000
Food was amazing and the staff was super friendly! Will visit again when in the area again!
Sue Whitney
2016-10-07T14:39:51+0000
Last night we had my son's wedding rehearsal dinner there. I had nevr been there. It was wonderful. Crystal made... planning easy,and her suggestions were spot on. Everyone loved the food from appetizers entrees and desserts. Casual atmosphere and competent wait staff. There were 20 of us from teenager to seventy year old and everyone loved it.read more
Jenn Kashella
2016-10-05T23:17:02+0000
So glad we decided to stop!! Will definitely be back again!! I have to add - Everything was delicious, but I really... enjoyed the ginger garlic green beans!! So garlicky and amazing!! And the house dressing on the salad was incredible! Our steaks were cooked exactly how we ordered them, too. �read more
Anne Harris Stamp
2016-09-19T18:32:30+0000
Wonderful food, service and atmosphere. Will definitely go again!
Noel Emilie
2016-09-08T13:13:45+0000
My fiancé and I stopped here for lunch. Amazing homemade food. Having desert is a must!
Justin Adams
2016-08-24T17:33:19+0000
Great service,awesome food,friendly atmosphere! The smoked wings are the best!
Elissa Good Smith
2016-08-13T00:20:22+0000
Delicious food, great drinks, fantastic service. Everyone wants to go back, including our 2 children! It's worth the... drive!!read more
Carol Gurnow
2016-08-06T22:50:21+0000
We enjoyed two fabulous meals this weekend made especially enjoyable by our most excellent server Abby! We have found... a new regular place! We will see you soon. Hope you have the steamed clam special .... So very yummy! Thank you !read more
Darrin Haight
2016-06-19T14:16:42+0000
Had reservations but no table. Ate out on the deck and an employee came out and smoked ten feet away from us! Son... ordered chicken wings and one had feathers, never seen that before! Service was ok but could of been better! They did take my sons wings off the bill. No hurry to go back!read more
Kay Galbreath Arnold
2016-05-09T23:47:35+0000
Great food and great service! Thank you so much! Everyone love their meal and how friendly everyone was. Great to see... you Crystal! Made my mom's day great! We will be back!!read more
Catherine Pesaresi Close
2016-05-08T20:55:20+0000
Amazingly delicious yet unpretentious. Melt in your mouth steaks, lobster ravioli with tons of real lobster meat,... super fresh salad greens. You have to trust their expertise. Some things they come up with you wouldn't ever think of but it's fabulous!! The pineapple sour cream dipping sauce for coconut crusted tiger shrimp. Omg!! Chocolate butter for fresh baked bread. Craziness but oooooh soooo good!!! There is something for everyone on this menu. They do it all very well. Service is friendly. Food is fresh and delicious. And it's a comfortable atmosphere. You don't need a suit and tie or evening gown. Can't wait to go back again. If you can save room for dessert.read more
Cat Cattan
2016-05-08T02:12:32+0000
Went there for the first time this evening , absolutely happily impressed, everthing was made fresh, nothing was... processed or premade,I had the filet mignon, wonderful, from the salad to the french onion soup, to the filet mignon with crab, everything was amazing and all fresh, my dining companion had the all American burger and was impressed with his dinner, we will definitely go back,looking forward to trying the Cornish game hens also,I can understand the owner's frustration at being confused with the old Manhattan's on the older reveiws on google, this resturant is new, has only been there about a year and shouldn't have to have their reveiws confused unfavorably with the previous business at that addressA Cattanread more
Jill Callard
2016-04-07T19:30:19+0000
Wonderful service! Wonderful food! We will be back for sure!!!
Lance Hickey
2016-03-19T02:31:38+0000
I had the opportunity to be a guest at the Hilltop tonight. It was a very enjoyable evening with very good food... quality with excellent service and friendly attitude from both bar and waiting staff. Congratulations from a very satisfied customer. from Napier, New Zealand.read more
Shannon Colley- Schultz
2016-03-15T23:51:59+0000
Not happy!!! Food orders were all wrong!! Noone ever checked on our drinks, my husband had water to drink and was... never offered more. Our first time there was our lastread more
Jillinda Prentice
2016-03-11T00:28:01+0000
Awesome dinner tonight , we will be back. Looking to try many more items. The fat bread pizza was great.
Debbie Foe
2016-03-03T21:25:16+0000
Really good food and our waiter Patrick was great. Can't wait to go back.
Shawna Baldwin
2016-02-26T19:52:02+0000
Crystal and Anthony made our parent's anniversary very special. Their staff service was excellent as well as the food!!... Top notch..very well done. Proud of you bothread more
Pamela J. Bochniarz
2016-02-18T01:41:30+0000
We went for the first time today. My husband had the wings and I had calamari and linguine with the Asiago cheese... sauce.. It was amazingread more
Kim A Morrell
2016-02-14T23:02:25+0000
Fantastic meal !! Prime Rib was served to perfection and the Lobster Risotto was out of this world!! The service was... prompt with excellent customer service. Thank you for a wonderful dinner!! We will be back.read more
Nicole Ann Bellnier
2016-02-03T19:37:08+0000
Best french dip I have ever had!! My husband loved his stuff peppers. Our waitress Chelsea was lovely and wonderful! ... Thanks Tony! Can't wait to come back again!read more
Rosanne Kilcullen
2016-02-01T16:15:47+0000
Friendly atmosphere and staff is awesome! The food is always prepared with love and is delicious! Not to miss, their... smoked chicken wings, to die for!!read more
Mike-Lori Tolli
2016-01-30T05:11:40+0000
Excellent food, drinks, staff & service. The owners are super sweet and a lot of fun!!!! The smoked style chicken wings... are super tender & melt in your mouth. 5 starsread more
John Leak
2016-01-26T02:03:59+0000
Go to hilltop whenwe are home in the summer visited hilltop frequently and outstanding restaurant from cocktails to... service to dinner one of the tops in New Yorkread more
Carol Mcdonald Slack
2016-01-17T23:25:10+0000
Made our first trip to Hilltop today, and it definitely won't be our last. I had the Pork Pit pulled pork sandwich and... the pasta salad of the day (broccoli & cheddar), and my husband had a Roast Beef sandwich and fries. My husband said it was the best roast beef he has had in recent memory, and my sandwich was phenomenal. The pasta salad was absolutely delicious! Hubby had a pop and I had water, and the bill only came to 21.03!!! Nice to find a place with great food, a nice welcoming atmosphere & friendly service, all at a great price. Can't wait for our next visit!read more
Donna Cooper Hill
2016-01-17T13:11:27+0000
Simply amazing. Crystal and her husband should be very proud. The food is delicious and the variety and quality is... fabulous.read more
Paul Elter
2016-01-03T22:29:37+0000
Great food and service. Chrystal is a hoot. Alot of fun beer choices as well
Linda Peace
2015-12-02T02:15:36+0000
Excellent food, excellent service. Everyone there was warm and friendly. Thank you. I definitely will be back.
Walter Conley
2015-11-29T02:53:21+0000
We went to the Hilltop with the MyPerks coupon. My Wife had the Chicken Alfredo and I the Yellow Fin Tuna. Outstanding... food. Will be back, The Hilltop is now on my favorites list for restaurantsread more
Sherry Mc Nair White
2015-11-19T22:41:29+0000
We went to the hilltop for our anniversary and I must say it was the best meal we had in a long time , the steak was so... tender and the mashed potato, garlicky good, steak sandwich with their sauces truly awesome, we will be back soon , tyread more
Carla Patterson
2015-11-15T01:47:40+0000
Excellent customer service 1st & foremost. Food is excellent (taste & appearance). Hilltop gained a new regular... customer with my family!read more
Winston Lloyd Jenkins III
2015-11-15T01:29:48+0000
Food tasted amazing! It is a nice friendly environment that is great for a reasonably priced family dinner.
Jesse AndHeather Harrington Cotriss
2015-10-18T01:44:09+0000
We loved our meals even our two year old loved his mac n cheese! We will be back!
Stephanie Gagliardi Wilson
2015-10-14T01:21:58+0000
Excellent, relaxed atmosphere with great food! Reasonably priced!